Have you ever wondered why the Monte Cristo sandwich is named after the famous novel? I have. I mean, it’s not like the count was dining on sandwiches dredged in cream and egg and topped with jam. He was in prison for a big chunk of the book. A bad prison where he had to tap on the walls to communicate with another prisoner. So not a friendly place.

It turns out that the sandwich is a variation on the Croque Monsieur—a grilled French ham and cheese sandwich with gruyere cheese and béchamel sauce. In English, that’s “Mr. Crunchy” to you. I’ve actually made this recipe, so I’m feeling a little embarrassed I never put two and two together.

Fun fact: the Croque Madame—the female version of the sandwich—is topped with an egg. So Mrs. Crunchy. 

 Anyway, I decided to give the Monte Cristo a go with Abigail’s Oven Country Loaf. 

Monte Cristo Sandwich

Serving Size:
1 sandwich
Time:
10 minutes
Difficulty:
moderate

Ingredients

  • 2 slices  Abigail’s Oven Country Loaf 
  • Mayonnaise, as needed
  • 2 slices Gruyere, Gouda or Havarti cheese
  • 2 thin slices of turkey
  • 3 large beaten eggs 
  • 1/4 cup cream or milk
  • 2 tablespoons olive oil
  • 1 tablespoon butter
  • Strawberries, blueberries, or orange slices, for garnish
  • Serve with jam (blue or blackberry)

Directions

  1. Layout 2 slices of sourdough bread and spread each with mayonnaise. On one slice, layer a slice of cheese and two slices of turkey topped with one more slice of cheese. Place the remaining slice of bread on the top layer of cheese.
  2. Cut the crusts from the sandwich. Wrap the sandwich tightly with plastic wrap and refrigerate for 30 minutes or up to 6 hours. Wrapping the sandwich in plastic wrap compacts it and prevents the egg batter from seeping in by sealing the edges.
  3. Combine the eggs and cream or milk in a bowl. In a skillet, heat the oil and butter over medium-high heat. Unwrap the sandwich and dip it into the egg batter, coating it evenly. Place it into the skillet; fry, turning once, until golden brown and hot, about 5 minutes.
  4. Cut the Monte Cristo in half and transfer it to a plate with garnish (strawberry slices and orange wedges). Spoon jam over each half and serve immediately.

A lot of recipes call for a third layer of bread (see image above), but after some thought, I decided to stick with two. Because what do people say when they heft our loaf for the first time? Oof, that’s heavy. (Kind of like at the Oscars.)

So yes, Abigail’s bread is a little heavier and denser than other varieties, while still managing to be deliciously tender—but I think a monte made with three layers of Country Loaf might taste like you’re eating all bread.

 I also chose Havarti because I happened to have some on hand. Most recipes call for Swiss. Next time I might try Gruyere.

 I used turkey and decided to go with the French toast method rather than deep frying. It just sounded better. But I’d like to try both versions, eventually.

The method that Mama’s on Washington Square uses, as featured by Food Network in this link, sounded great to me. They cut the crusts off and cover the sandwich in plastic wrap, thus pinching the sides together, and leave it in the fridge for at least 30 minutes. This keeps the batter from infiltrating the insides of your sandwich. It worked pretty well. This recipe also recommends gouda cheese, and that sounds pretty wonderful, too.

I was very pleased with the results. The sourdough did not take away from the sweetness. I served it with blueberry jam and a dusting of powdered sugar. I think the deep-fry method would make it more scone-like, which might be even better.